positive signage

In the ASLA policy committee discussion this morning, we had a rousing discussion about how to update the billboards policy, especially with the proliferation of electronic signage and supergraphics.

Our consensus was that signs (of all sorts) should reinforce a sense of place. Banners, bus shelters, other street furniture, bus wraps, sidewalk stickers, and billboards all add to visual clutter of cities (and highways). There are notorious examples of billboards causing a public nuisance, such as the traffic jams in Chicago at the Dennis Rodman billboard.

There is a place in the built environment for graphics and signs, but the status quo in which outdoor advertisers do what they please, and regularly flaunt the law, should not be tolerated. I certainly see a stark distinction between commercial speech and what the first amendment protects. I’m glad that there are folks mobilized to fight billboards and even studies providing solid justification for the removal of all billboards.

Up in the Owens Valley, I’ve been struck by the saturation of bill boards on the Piute-Shoshone Reservation in contrast with the billboard free remainder of the Valley. While I applaud the entrepreneurial spirit of the tribe, I really question if their gains outweigh the blight? This is a clear example of the social and environmental justice aspect of outdoor advertising exploiting lower income and politically disenfranchised areas.

To finish with a good example of environmental graphics, below is the Greenpix Zero Energy Media Wall in Beijing.

2 thoughts on “positive signage

  1. Barry,
    Why is Greenpix Zero Energy Media Wall in Beijing a good example? Because it is zero energy?

    Seems visually invasive.

    • good question. It stands out because it responds to it’s environment in a way to enhance it’s place. being green is a plus, but that’s not why I chose it. There are other buildings/dynamic facades that also respond to their environment to in a way that also enhance their surroundings, but I think the Media Wall is the best (so far).

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s